York County News

Pennsylvania's state-controlled system for the sale of wine and spirits, established in 1933 by Governor Gifford Pinchot after the repeal of prohibition, is facing renewed calls for privatization. Senator Mike Regan argues that nearly 90 years later, it is time to end this government monopoly.

Governor Pinchot's plan initially faced opposition due to fears it would create a "political machine" and lead to "a second era of prohibition for Pennsylvania." These concerns have persisted, with current members of Pinchot’s party now opposing the system. The political influence of unions representing state store workers, such as the United Food and Commercial Workers Union (UFCW), is cited as a reason for its continuation.

The UFCW leader reportedly earns over $400,000 annually, prioritizing personal gain over consumer interests. The union also contributes millions to political candidates' campaigns and uses its influence to oppose privatization efforts.

Senator Regan highlights that separating politics from any issue is challenging but believes it's possible to separate state government from alcohol sales. He points out that while the Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board (PLCB) claims increased profits, they do not disclose product markups or significant pension liabilities. The PLCB and UFCW argue against privatization due to potential societal impacts but simultaneously use marketing strategies to increase alcohol sales.

Regan criticizes the PLCB for not carding customers like other retailers and suggests their focus on profit ignores consumer demands for convenience and selection. He argues that restricting adult access based on location reflects an outdated system rooted in prohibition.

Advocates for maintaining the current system include Governor Wolf and the UFCW, who also support mixed drinks to-go legislation. Regan questions this stance when arguing against privatization on grounds of easier alcohol access.

He further notes that limiting product availability at state stores drives residents across state lines for purchases, impacting local revenue and potentially criminalizing those who bring alcohol back into Pennsylvania.

As 2022 approaches, Senator Regan supports Representative Natalie Mihalek’s efforts towards liquor sales privatization in Pennsylvania and encourages legislative and public backing.

Senator Mike Regan serves as Chairman of the Senate Law and Justice Committee representing parts of Cumberland and York Counties in Pennsylvania's 31st Senatorial District.